Should You Refinance Your Car Loan? How to Tell If It Saves Money
The short answer
Refinancing replaces your current car loan with a new one, ideally at a lower APR. It saves money when the new loan’s total cost (payments plus fees) is lower than what you’d pay by keeping your current loan. Watch for two traps: a longer term that lowers the payment but adds interest, and fees or prepayment penalties that eat up the savings.
A worked example
You owe $20,000 at 9% APR with 48 months left. Your payment is $497.70, and you have $3,889.61 of interest still to pay. A lender offers 6% APR. Here are three ways to take it, calculated with our car payment calculator (enter the balance as the price):
| Option | Monthly payment | Interest left to pay | Total you’ll pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keep current loan (9%, 48 months) | $497.70 | $3,889.61 | $23,889.61 |
| Refinance at 6%, 48 months | $469.70 | $2,545.66 | $22,545.66 |
| Refinance at 6%, 48 months, $300 fee financed | $476.75 | $2,583.78 | $22,883.78 |
| Refinance at 6%, 60 months | $386.66 | $3,199.35 | $23,199.35 |
What this shows:
- Same term, lower rate: you save $1,343.95. That’s the cleanest win.
- With a $300 fee: you still save $1,005.83, but less. Always include fees.
- Longer term: the payment drops by $111 a month, but you save only $690.26 overall, and you’ll be paying for an extra year. The CFPB notes that a longer term can lower your payments but usually increases the total interest you pay.
When refinancing makes sense
- Your credit has improved since you took out the loan.
- Rates are lower now than when you borrowed.
- You financed at the dealership without comparing offers, and a bank or credit union now offers a lower APR.
- You need a lower payment to stay current. In that case a longer term may be worth the extra interest, but know the trade-off.
When it may not be worth it
- Little time left on the loan. Most of the interest has already been paid in the early years (see how amortization works), so there’s less left to save.
- A prepayment penalty. Refinancing means paying off your old loan. The CFPB notes you may owe a fee if your current agreement has a prepayment penalty.
- You owe more than the car is worth. Many lenders won’t refinance an underwater loan, or will charge more. See negative equity.
- Fees cancel the savings. Ask about application, origination and title-transfer fees, and compare APRs, which include lender fees.
Checklist before you refinance
- Get your current payoff amount and months remaining from your lender.
- Check your contract for a prepayment penalty.
- Get quotes from two or three lenders and compare APR to APR.
- Run your current loan and each offer through the calculator, with fees included, and compare total you’ll pay.
- Prefer the same or a shorter term, unless you specifically need a lower payment.
- If you bought GAP or a service contract with your original loan, ask about a refund when the old loan is paid off. See GAP insurance.
Try your own numbers with the calculator.
Sources
- CFPB: What should I do if I can't make my car payments? (accessed November 17, 2026)
- CFPB: Can I prepay my loan at any time without penalty? (accessed November 17, 2026)
- CFPB: What is the difference between a loan interest rate and the APR? (accessed November 17, 2026)